You might, before doing anything else, read this and learn about the way in which the courts have been packed to protect the corporate polluters…

JUDICIAL

JUDICIAL

JUDICIAL

The Judicial Branch of the federal government is responsible for interpreting and reviewing the country’s laws. The Supreme Court is the most powerful body of the Judicial Branch. About 8,000 cases are filed with the Supreme Court each year, but only about 80 are chosen to be heard and decided by the Court. The Supreme Court is the only court where the Justices make the decision whether or not to hear a case. Most often, a case makes it to the Supreme Court after the plaintiffs involved appeal the ruling of one of the US Courts of Appeal.

There are numerous cases weaving their way through the courts. Exxon Mobil, for example, is facing a wave of lawsuits driven in large part by revelations which began surfacing in 2015.  These revelations indicated that the climate crisis was not the result of blind error, or even willful ignorance, but rather calculated abuses of power.  Exxon had conducted scientific studies that showed the warming effect of carbon emissions and predicted the dire consequences of climate change, before spending millions on misinformation to derail regulation and solidify international dependence on fossil fuels. Massachusetts and New York have both sued Exxon for fraud.

Meanwhile, cities like San Francisco, New York City, Richmond and others have filed suits for damages from climate change against companies like Chevron, BP, Shell, and ConocoPhillips in addition to Exxon. Several high-profile cases challenging the expansion of oil pipelines are also being litigated.

And, then there is the landmark case of Juliana v. US, brought by 21 young people in 2015, which argues that the federal government’s duty to serve as a trustee of resources extends to the atmosphere, and that it had thus failed in that constitutional duty. A full and fascinating history of this litigation can be found here.

Just as many of these cases are winding their way through the courts, the makeup of the highest court in the land has changed dramatically. Following the death of renowned Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on September 18, 2020, Trump filled her seat with Amy Coney Barrett on September 26th. Barrett promises to shift the court to the far right for decades to come and environmental organizations have already expressed concern that she will be favorable towards fossil fuel companies.

Most recently, on October 2, 2020, the Supreme Court agreed to review a Fourth Circuit ruling that a Baltimore suit — seeking to put energy giants like Chevron and ExxonMobil on the hook for climate related infrastructure damages — belonged in state court.

What Is the Judicial Branch of the U.S. Government? | History

CURRENT NEWS

KEY RESOURCES

The Lawfarm Climatechange scorecard

01/27/21
Climate Scores For Vault 100 Law Firms 1

U.S. Climate Change Litigation

08/20/20
Cases in the U.S. database are organized by type of claim and may be filtered by the principal laws they address, their filing years, and their jurisdictions. The database is also searchable by keyword. In…

Mapped: Climate change laws around the world

03/05/20
There has been a 20-fold increase in the number of global climate change laws since 1997, according to the most comprehensive database of relevant policy and legislation.

Congress and Climate Change

03/05/20
Federal efforts to address climate change are undertaken under laws, and with funding, approved by Congress. Like other complex economy-wide challenges, climate change touches on a wide array of interests. The stakes vary from sector…

Our Focus: Climate Change

03/05/20
Climate change is not a new challenge for CLF. We’ve been working to address its root causes for decades and have played a part in critical milestones to curb its progress. We helped design the…

Environmental Law 101: Climate Change

03/05/20
A short, but thorough, introduction from a leading environmental law think tank on climate change and what is being done to combat it through legal action and policy.

Federal Action on Climate

03/05/20
Given the far-reaching nature of the climate challenge, effective federal policy is needed to achieve deep, long-term reductions in U.S. greenhouse gas emissions, and to help strengthen climate resilience across the U.S. economy. Even in…

Judicial – Key resources – content to come

08/02/19
[vc_row][vc_column][vc_empty_space height="50px"][/vc_column][/vc_row]

MORE NEWS

Judge throws out Trump rule limiting what science EPA can use

By Juliet Eilperin  Photo by Jabin Botsford   02/02/21  
A federal judge on Monday vacated the Trump administration rule limiting which scientific studies the Environmental Protection Agency can use in crafting public health protections, overturning one of the last major actions taken by the…

Court Voids a ‘Tortured’ Trump Climate Rollback

By Lisa Friedman  Photo by Scott Olson   01/19/21  
A federal appeals court on Tuesday struck down the Trump administration’s plan to relax restrictions on greenhouse gas emissions from power plants, paving the way for President-elect Joseph R. Biden Jr. to enact new and…

Oil companies fight to get climate cases before Supreme Court

By James Osborne   12/15/20  
Some of the world’s largest oil companies are hoping to convince the U.S. Supreme Court to decide whether they should be held liable for climate change. In the middle of a years-long legal fight with…

By Calling Climate Change ‘Controversial,’ Barrett Created Controversy

By John Schwartz and Hiroko Tabuchi   10/15/20  
Judge Amy Coney Barrett refused to answer numerous questions, but it was her avoidance of acknowledging climate change that particularly resonated.

Could Barrett ‘shut the courthouse doors’ on enviros?

By Pamela King  Photo by Alex Brandon   09/26/20  
President Trump today selected Amy Coney Barrett to fill the seat of the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on the nation's highest bench.

Climate battles moving into court, lawyers getting creative

07/06/20  
Two decades ago, only a handful of climate-related lawsuits had ever been filed worldwide. Today, that number is 1,600, including 1,200 lawsuits in the United States alone, according to data reported Friday by the London…

Climate Change Litigants Argue Human Rights, Consumer Harm in Suing Oil Firms

By Matthew Green, Valerie Volcovici and Emma Farge   07/06/20  
In the Netherlands in December, the country’s Supreme Court upheld a ruling in favor of the Urgenda campaign group’s demand that the Dutch government move faster to cut carbon emissions.

Court orders Dakota Access Pipeline to shut down

By Rachel Frazin   07/06/20  
Judge James Boasberg on Monday ruled that the pipeline has to be shut down within 30 days while the Army Corps of Engineers works to prepare an environmental impact statement for a rule relaxation that…

House Democrats just put out the most detailed climate plan in US political history

By David Roberts   06/30/20  
In 2007, shortly after Democrats took back the House of Representatives in the 2006 midterm elections, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi created the House Select Committee on Energy Independence and Global Warming, meant to gather expert…

Are matters of national survival related to climate change really beyond a court’s power?

By: Sophie Marjanac & Sam Hunter Jones  Photo by Patrick Pleul   06/28/20  
Courts can adjudicate the effectiveness of emissions reduction policies in protecting fundamental rights without encroaching on the powers of the political branches of government.

Fossil Fuel Companies and Their Supporters Ask Supreme Court to Intervene in Climate Lawsuits

By Dana Drugmand   06/23/20  
“The Ninth Circuit ruling identifies the main reason this case and all climate tort litigation is not suited for federal or state court,” he wrote, adding the ruling “underscores why the U.S. Supreme Court should…

Texas court says it can’t derail ‘ugly’ climate change lawsuits though it would like to

By John O'Brien   06/22/20  
The court said it felt an impulse to protect the energy industry but could not retain jurisdiction on the case. It also criticized the cities and counties that have hired private lawyers instead of pushing…

Climate-Change ‘Lawfare’: Texas Judges Take Swipe at California’s Liberal Courts, Reluctantly Ruling Against Exxon

By Angela Morris   06/19/20  
In the case, Exxon was litigating to obtain pre-lawsuit depositions to see if California litigation against it regarding climate change was brought in bad faith, just to try to suppress the company’s speech on climate…

Florida youths’ climate change lawsuit dismissed, will appeal

By Michelle Lewis   06/17/20  
You’re reading Electrek— experts who break news about Tesla, electric vehicles, and green energy, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow Electrek on Twitter, Facebook,…

INSIGHT: State Courts Are a Proper Climate Change Battleground

By Tim McMahan and Jose Abarca  Photo by David Paul Morris   06/12/20  
On appeal in the City of Oakland, the Ninth Circuit first considered whether the district court erred in denying the municipalities’ motions to remand based on its determination that it had federal-question jurisdiction under 28…

Court strikes down 440 oil and gas leases across the West

By Rebecca Beitsch   05/26/20  
A federal court in Montana invalidated 440 oil and gas leases sold across the West, ruling Friday the Trump administration did not properly follow a plan to protect sage grouse habitat.

E.U. Proposes a Climate Law. Greta Thunberg Hears ‘Empty Words.’

By Monika Pronczuk  Photo: Petr David Josek/AP   03/04/20  
The bill would set a target of net zero carbon emissions across the bloc by 2050. That is decades later than what many activists say is needed.

E.P.A. Updates Plan to Limit Science Used in Environmental Rules

By Lisa Friedman  Photo: Alyssa Schukar for NYT   03/04/20  
The Trump administration has formally revised a proposal that would significantly restrict the type of research that can be used to draft environmental and public health regulations, a measure that experts say amounts to one…

Republicans are making noises on climate action. Some say it’s just greenwashing

By Emily Holden  Photo: Jim Lo Scalzo/EPA   03/02/20  
Bills to meet environmental targets while feeding industry have the right pushing back and experts unconvinced

Judge voids nearly 1 million acres of oil and gas leases, saying Trump policy undercut public input

By Juliet Eilperin and Darryl Fears  Photo by David Zalubowski/AP   02/29/20  
A federal judge in Idaho has voided nearly 1 million acres of oil and gas leases on federal lands in the West, saying that a Trump administration policy that limited public input on those leases…

Fossil Fuels on Trial: Where the Major Climate Change Lawsuits Stand Today

By David Hasemyer  Photo: Justin Sullivan/Getty   01/17/20  
Some of the biggest oil and gas companies are embroiled in legal disputes with cities, states and children over the industry's role in global warming.

New Trump rule would allow government to ignore climate impacts of major projects

By Jean Chemnick  Photo: Gage Skidmore/ Wikimedia Commons   01/09/20  
It took seven years for President Barack Obama to get federal agencies on the same page about considering the climate impacts of proposed projects. That could be reversed for good by regulations expected to be…

2020: A Year of Pipeline Court Fights, with One Lawsuit Headed to the Supreme Court

By Phil McKenna   01/03/20  
After years of mounting opposition to the increasing build-out of oil and gas infrastructure, 2020 is shaping up to be the year that pipeline opponents get their day in court.
Vox

Nearly a fifth of US emissions come from public lands. A new House bill aims to cut them to zero by 2040.

By Umair Irfan  Photo: Robert Nickelsberg/Getty   12/17/19  
The House Natural Resources Committee just introduced one of the most aggressive climate bills of the current Congress.

The Climate-Change Lawsuit Debacle

By Curt Levey  Photo: Drew Angerer/Getty   12/17/19  
A New York judge rules in favor of Exxon Mobil and deals humiliation to the state attorney general.

3rd Circ. Gives States Extra Weapon To Fight Gas Pipelines

09/11/19  
As the Trump administration moves to limit states' ability to review and potentially block interstate gas pipelines, the Third Circuit gave states a powerful backup option to veto projects in a ruling that pipeline developers…
Vox

The Supreme Court is about to decide if the children’s climate lawsuit can proceed

By Umair Irfan  Photo by Robin Loznak   10/30/18  
One of the biggest legal battles over climate change is now in limbo pending a decision from the Supreme Court’s chief justice, who took the odd step of halting the lawsuit to consider a stay.…