CARBON PRICING

CARBON PRICING

It is generally accepted by climate-change activists that burning fossil fuels, which put CO2 into our ecosystem, is the principal cause of climate change. And it is generally accepted that “putting a price on carbon”, taxing the fuels that emit the CO2 (and therefore price-favoring energy sources that do not) is a useful strategy.

Putting a price on carbon can be done two different ways. One is called “cap and trade” — setting limits on how much CO2 we will accept and selling “permits” to burn the fossil fuel that will produce that limited amount. The demand for those licenses effectively determines the price paid for them.

The other method is simply to “tax” the fossil fuels based on the emissions they generate.

There is a difference of opinion among activists about which is better. But the big differences of opinion, the ones that cause disagreements that slow down the efforts to put a price on carbon, are about “what to do with the revenue raised”.

Dedicated activists often want to devote those revenues to promote green energy or to redress people suffering climate injustice. Other activists (including one of the founders of this site) support carbon-fee-and-dividend, by which all the revenue raised pricing carbon is simply returned in equal shares to everybody. This approach has the advantage of being much more politically palatable since most people — 70 percent or more — get more back in their carbon “dividend” than the fees cost them in increased energy costs.

Our own Mike Shatzkin spoke to these issues at the Sarasota Institute in the spring of 2020.

Carbon pricing | ACCIONA Sustainability

CURRENT NEWS

KEY RESOURCES

How Carbon Dioxide Emissions Would Respond to a Tax

02/17/22
CBO and the staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation projected the budgetary effects and the change in emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) and other greenhouse gases (GHGs) that would stem from a potential tax…

FIVE THINGS TO KNOW ABOUT CARBON PRICING

09/16/21
Deterring the use of fossil fuels, such as coal, fuel oil, and gasoline, is crucial to reducing the buildup of heat-trapping greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. Carbon pricing provides across-the-board incentives to reduce energy use…

Key to Biden Climate Agenda: The Social Cost of Carbon Explained

02/08/21
Michael Greenstone, EPIC Director, said reverting to the Obama-era calculations would yield a social cost of carbon of $125 per ton, assuming it took into account lower interest rates in recent years.

Report of the High-Level Commission on Carbon Pricing and Competitiveness

10/01/20
The potentially adverse impact of carbon pricing on the competitiveness of businesses and economies has been a matter of concern to industry and policymakers.

Putting a Price on Carbon: Evaluating A Carbon Price and Complementary Policies for a 1.5° World

10/01/20
Putting a price on carbon is necessary to reduce emissions but sufficient to get to full decarbonization by 2050. Complementary policies with a carbon price are needed to achieve full decarbonization.

Carbon Pricing

08/11/20
The Nicholas Institute assesses carbon pricing schemes for environmental integrity, cost-effectiveness, and distributional equity. Since the 2007 landmark Supreme Court decision Massachusetts v. EPA, we have explored carbon trading as a method for regulating emissions…

Why Price Carbon?

08/11/20
There is widespread recognition and scientific consensus that in order to stabilize the climate and prevent the worst consequences of the climate crisis, greenhouse gas emissions must be reduced by at least 80 percent by…

Carbon Pricing 101

08/11/20
When carbon emissions cost money, we produce less of them.

How Can the US Reduce Climate Change? Carbon Pricing

08/11/20
Q&A with Frank Wolak, director of the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies (FSI)’s Program on Energy and Sustainable Development(PESD), and Mark Thurber, associate director for research of PESD. Written with Joshua Kenway.

Carbon Tax Research Initiative

08/11/20
Climate change presents serious threats to the economy, the environment and national security. To address these threats, a growing number of influential businesses, scientists, NGOs, policymakers, and thought leaders are calling for a carbon tax,…

Carbon Pricing 101

07/24/20
An introduction to carbon pricing, including carbon taxes and cap-and-trade programs, the benefits and design of pricing policies, and applications around the globe.

What is Carbon Pricing?

07/24/20
Carbon pricing is an approach to reducing carbon emissions (also referred to as greenhouse gas, or GHG, emissions) that uses market mechanisms to pass the cost of emitting on to emitters. Its broad goal is…

U.S. State Carbon Pricing Policies

06/01/19
Compared to command-and-control regulations, carbon pricing is a market-based mechanism that creates financial incentives to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Ten states that are home to over a quarter of the U.S. population and account…

Citizens Climate Lobby

01/19/19
Citizens’ Climate Lobby is a non-profit, non-partisan, grassroots advocacy organization focused on national policies to address climate change. By building upon shared values rather than partisan divides, and empowering our supporters to work in keeping…

Carbon Pricing as a Solution to Climate Change

02/14/20
FCNL believes that carbon pricing is one of many essential tools that Congress should use to address climate change and shift towards a clean energy economy. While we have not endorsed any particular bill at…

MORE NEWS

Carbon Fees Could Lead to Substantially Lower Emissions

By David Worford   11/29/21  
Carbon fees implemented across industries could significantly reduce energy-related emissions in the United States, according to an analysis by the US Energy Information Administration (EIA).

Pricing carbon is vital to US climate goals and politically unlikely, but there is another way, analysts say

By Herman K. Trabish  Photo: Getty Images   11/24/21  
Imposing a federal price on carbon to drive decarbonization is both urgent and unlikely, but there may be a workaround, according to some economists and policymakers.

The Latest Farm Product: Carbon Credits

By Elizabeth G. Dunn  Photo: Rachel Mummey , The New York Times   11/23/21  
Eight years ago, Kevin Prevo started making changes to the land in southern Iowa that his family has farmed for five generations. Mr. Prevo stopped tilling the fields between crop cycles and started planting cover…

Is 24/7 carbon-free energy the right goal?

By David Roberts   11/19/21  
Last week, I wrote an introduction to the hot new trend in energy: 24/7 carbon-free energy (CFE), i.e., matching a company or city’s power consumption with production of clean electricity throughout the day, every hour…

If the world loves forests, it should put a price on their carbon

11/06/21  
THE WORLD'S leaders may quail at extinguishing coal-fired plants or raising petrol prices, but they can be relied upon to embrace one ally in the fight against climate change: the tree. For all his claims…

President Biden’s Silk Purse: Young People Will Sit in Judgment

By James E. Hansen  Photo: Earth Institute at Columbia University   10/26/21  
My talk described the danger of climate change and the fundamental actions needed to avert that danger. The existential threat is the potential to initiate unstoppable sea level rise to a level that causes loss…

Opinion: Why the U.S. refusal to tax carbon creates a windfall for Saudi Arabia and Russia

By the Editorial Board  Photo: Maxim Shemetov/Reuters   10/16/21  
There are two big risks in the world’s impending transition to a low-carbon energy future. The first, of course, is that it may fail to achieve sufficient emissions reductions to prevent a climate debacle. The…

Why the US should establish a carbon price either through reconciliation or other legislation

By Sanjay Patnaik and Kelly Kennedy   10/07/21  
From the start of his term, President Biden has indicated that he wishes to pursue an ambitious climate agenda. On his first day in office, he recommitted the U.S. to the Paris Climate Agreement and…

Carbon tax fight brews among Democrats

By Nick Sobczyk, Geof Koss, Emma Dumain  Photo: Francis Chung/E&E News   09/29/21  
Carbon pricing is back in the climate change conversation, but House and Senate Democrats are at odds about the policy as reconciliation talks reach a breaking point. Senate Finance Chair Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) is pushing…

Doubts shroud climate program

By Evan Halper  Photo: Carolyn Cole , Los Angeles Times   09/20/21  
As fire ripped through the Mendocino County hills the summer of 2018, burning a vast expanse of forest and turning buildings to ash, a curious thing was happening at Eddie Ranch, a sprawling property scorched by the…

OECD boss: Carbon pricing should come through us

By Bjarke Smith-Meyer  Photo: Clemens Bilan , Getty Images   09/11/21  
Efforts to price carbon should be elevated to the international level, the head of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development told EU finance ministers Saturday.
WSJ

Energy Traders See Big Money in Carbon-Emissions Markets

By Sarah Mcfarlane   09/01/21  
Big energy trading houses, long focused on deep, volatile markets such as oil and natural gas, are now bulking up their carbon-trading operations as governments around the world push to expand the market for trading…

Carbon Tax, Beloved Policy to Fix Climate Change, Is Dead at 47

By Robinson Meyer  Photo: Jeff Swensen/Getty   07/21/21  
The American carbon tax, an alluringly simple policy once hailed by environmentalists, scholars, and politicians as a cure-all for climate change that, for all its elegance in economic models, could not overcome its enduring unpopularity…

Democrats Propose a Border Tax Based on Countries’ Greenhouse Gas Emissions

By Lisa Friedman  Photo: Al Drago for The New York Times   07/19/21  
Democratic lawmakers on Monday proposed to raise as much as $16 billion annually by imposing a tax on imports from China and other countries that are not significantly reducing the planet-warming pollution that they produce.

Carbon border taxes are defensible but bring great risks

Photo: Getty Images   07/15/21  
Carbon prices are the most cost-effective way to fight climate change—but for them to work properly, emissions must be priced everywhere. On July 14th the European Commission unveiled its plan to levy what would, in effect,…

How digitizing global supply chains will advance the circular economy

By Georgia Sherwin   06/24/21  
For all of the wrong reasons, global trade and supply chain logistics have been front of mind this year. When consumers get what they want, when they want it, they typically don’t ask too many…

Pacific islands make lonely case for carbon price on shipping

By Joe Lo  Photo: Genevieve French/Greenpeace   06/16/21  
Pacific island nations made the case for a carbon price to tackle shipping’s climate impact at the UN body responsible for seaborne transport on Wednesday, but found only tepid support. At a environmental committee meeting…

This Is How the Fashion Industry Will Reduce Its Carbon Footprint

By Arielle Crawford   06/14/21  
After yet another confused Earth Week and global climate summit, it’s clear that the U.S. has no idea how to address climate change. Vague, meandering pledges about emissions reductions take the stage, while Instagram has…

Biden should impose a carbon fee immediately

By James E. Hansen and Daniel M. Galpern  Photo: Charlie Riedel/Associated Press   06/01/21  
President Biden has inherited a welter of urgent challenges, which he and his team are confronting with alacrity and skilled professionalism. In this moment, he has an exceptional opportunity to address, as he so aptly…

How much damage does climate change cause in Colorado?

By Mark Jaffe  Photo: Hugh Carey/The Colorado Sun   05/25/21  
The East Troublesome fire, Colorado’s second largest ever, was sweeping across Grand County forests on Oct. 25, 2020, part of a record-breaking wildfire season that forced evacuations, destroyed homes and took lives. Half a world…

Close to Home: For wineries, a carbon tax is pro-business

By Robin Lail and Beth Novak Milliken  Photo: Peter Dasilva / New York Times   05/23/21  
Drought, heat extremes, wildfires, power outages, smoke — in the past four years these have become part of our normal experience in the Napa Valley and in all winegrowing regions in the western United States.

Washington Passed its Cap-and-Trade Climate Legislation. Now What?

By Levi Pulkkinen  Photo: Ted S. Warren/ap   05/10/21  
Washington state lawmakers have passed a sweeping set of environmental regulations meant to cut net greenhouse gas emissions to zero by 2050 while pumping billions of dollars into the state coffers and addressing environmental racism.…

Researchers demonstrate how carbon taxes can reduce global poverty . . . not exacerbate it

By Sarah DeWeerdt   05/04/21  
The burden of climate change will fall disproportionately on the world’s poor: economic damage from increased temperatures will be worse in the Global South, and within any given country climate disruptions affect poorer people more.…

The Climate Solution Actually Adding Millions of Tons of CO2 Into the Atmosphere

By Lisa Song and James Temple  Photo: Jon Han   04/29/21  
Along the coast of Northern California near the Oregon border, the cool, moist air off the Pacific sustains a strip of temperate rainforests. Soaring redwoods and Douglas firs dominate these thick, wet woodlands, creating a…

Economists: A US carbon tax would be progressive

By Gilbert E. Metcalf and Lawrence Goulder  Photo: istock   04/28/21  
Environmental justice concerns have been at the forefront in discussions of U.S. environmental policy. They have been central, in particular, to discussions of proposals for a nationwide carbon tax to address climate change. While economists…

Opinion: Biden’s climate plan is a risky bet for the planet

Photo: Andrew Harnik   04/15/21  
Environmentalists have tried many approaches to promote climate-change legislation: a big cap-and-trade proposal; small amendments to must-pass bills; tiny changes to the tax code. Their success has been limited. Now Democrats are trying a new…

Big Businesses Say They Want a Price on Carbon

By Nick Sobczyk  Photo: Bill Clark/Getty Images   04/14/21  
Executives from oil companies, utilities and some of the world’s biggest companies are meeting with senators and staff this week to push a carbon-fee-and-dividend proposal.

Oil, gas industry says it will support carbon pricing

By Steven Mufson and Joshua Partlow  Photo by Angus Mordant   03/26/21  
The American Petroleum Institute, the leading oil and gas lobbying group, on Thursday backed the idea of the government putting a price on carbon emissions, provided the Biden administration avoids other measures the group terms…

Breakingviews – Breakdown: Carbon border tax isn’t about carbon

By Gina Chon   03/23/21  
The idea of a carbon border tax is gaining ground in the European Union and the United States. It looks like a win in the fight against climate change. But such policies could also level…

U.S. drillers, miners would be out billions if paid climate, health costs: study

By Reuters Staff   03/23/21  
U.S. coal, natural gas and motor fuel producers get implicit benefits worth tens of billion of dollars a year by not having to pay for the damage their products do to the climate and human…
WSJ

Oil Company Leaders Support Carbon Pricing Plan

By Timothy Puko  Photo by Stefani Reynolds   03/22/21  
Top oil company executives, in a meeting with White House officials Monday, expressed support for putting a price on carbon emissions as a means to address greenhouse gas emissions that contribute to climate change. White…

A New Vision for the US Climate Agenda

By Ian Parry   03/10/21  
Over the next decade, global greenhouse gas emissions need to be cut by 25– 50 percent to be on track for meeting the 2015 Paris Agreement goal of containing global warming to 1.5–2°C.The United States…

12 states sue Biden over ‘social cost’ calculation of greenhouse gases

By Rachel Frazin   03/08/21  
Twelve states are suing the Biden administration for trying to establish a "social cost" of greenhouse gases to use in agency rulemaking. In a lawsuit filed on Monday, the states argued that a January executive…

Biden Administration Sets Social Cost Of Carbon At $51 Per Ton

By Steve Hanley   03/06/21  
The Biden administration has set the social cost of carbon at $51 per ton — 7 times higher than the price set by the prior administration. What does that mean? Economists talk about “untaxed externalities”…

Top oil and gas lobbying group close to backing a carbon tax

By Steven Mufson  Photo by David Paul Morris   03/03/21  
The American Petroleum Institute, the oil and gas industry’s top lobbying arm, is edging closer to endorsing a carbon tax, a tool that would make fossil fuels more expensive, boost prospects for renewable and nuclear…

Oil Trade Group Is Poised to Endorse Carbon Pricing

By Ted Mann and Timothy Puko  Photo by Matthew Busch   03/01/21  
The oil industry’s top lobbying group is preparing to endorse setting a price on carbon emissions in what would be the strongest signal yet that oil and gas producers are ready to accept government efforts…

Cost of Carbon Pollution Pegged at $51 a Ton

By Jean Chemnick  Photo: Credit: David Paul Morris/Getty Images   03/01/21  
Contributing to climate change is once again expensive—at least in the eyes of the federal government. That’s after the Biden administration on Friday raised the social cost of carbon to about $51 per ton. The…

Biden is hiking the cost of carbon. It will change how the U.S. tackles global warming

By Juliet Eilperin and Brady Dennis  Photo by Jonathan Newton   02/27/21  
President Biden on Friday dramatically altered the way the U.S. government calculates the real-world cost of climate change, a move that could reshape a range of consequential decisions, from whether to allow new coal leasing…

George Shultz — an environmentalist and technologist ahead of his time

By Susan Hockfield and Ernest J. Moniz  Photo by Andrew Harrer   02/23/21  
In 2006, we established a campus-wide, cross-disciplinary energy program, the MIT Energy Initiative, to develop new solutions to climate change. The success of our outsized ambition to accelerate academic discovery that translated into industry applications…

Eight priorities for calculating the social cost of carbon

By Gernot Wagner   02/19/21  
One of the first executive orders US President Joe Biden signed in January began a process to revise the social cost of carbon (SCC). This metric is used in cost–benefit analyses to inform climate policy.…
UPI

Scientists explore how to recalculate the social cost of carbon

By Brooks Hays  Photo by Ryan Tong   02/19/21  
President Joe Biden and his administration want to recalibrate the "social cost of carbon," a metric used to inform public policy decision making by putting a price on the non-market impacts of carbon emissions on…

A Carbon Tax in the Context of Budget Reconciliation

By Joseph Majkut   02/18/21  
Budget reconciliation is an expedited legislative process under which Congress can accomplish budgetary priorities through changes to revenues and spending. A carbon tax instituted as a budgetary measure would allow Congress to raise a significant…

The Most Important Number You’ve Never Heard Of

By Eric Roston  Photo by Andrew Harrer   01/22/21  
If prices for fossil fuels reflected their true cost to society—in deadly heat waves, water stress, disappearing crops—they’d be a lot higher than they are now. How much higher? Ask Michael Greenstone.

Charge a new fee on carbon emissions to combat climate change

By Shreyas Jagtap  Photo: Getty   01/15/21  
The increased cost of fossil fuels would push companies to move faster toward renewable sources of energy.

Energy implications of Biden’s latest Cabinet picks

Ben Geman  Photo: Paul Morigi, Paul Marotta, and Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images   01/08/21  
President-elect Joe Biden's final burst of Cabinet picks could have important roles to play in the new administration's climate change and energy agenda.

Europe’s carbon border tax puts pressure on U.S. to enact carbon price

11/18/20  
President-elect Joe Biden comes into office with an ambitious agenda to tackle climate change. How much of that agenda is achievable, however, depends on the outcome of two Senate runoffs in Georgia on Jan. 5.…

Bag the Carbon Calculators. You Didn’t Cause This.

By Peter Sinclair   10/08/20  
It’s here that British Petroleum, or BP, first promoted and soon successfully popularized the term “carbon footprint” in the early aughts. The company unveiled its “carbon footprint calculator” in 2004 so one could assess how…

In contentious vote, Pennsylvania takes formal step towards joining regional cap and trade market

By Robert Walton   09/16/20  
The Pennsylvania Environmental Quality Board (EQB) on Tuesday voted 13-6 to launch a formal rulemaking process required for the state to join the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI), a carbon cap and trade program among…
Vox

How to drive fossil fuels out of the US economy, quickly

By David Roberts  Photo: Hyoung Chang/The Denver Post via Getty Images   08/06/20  
The US has everything it needs to decarbonize by 2035.

Carbon pricing isn’t just blowing smoke

By Sarah DeWeerdt   07/21/20  
The largest study on the topic to date demonstrates that the higher a country’s carbon price, the more it reduces emissions.